You are Johnny Depp. Your professional life, largely built on the goodwill and affection associated with your name, or at least with Captain Jack Sparrow’s, is in significant disarray.
A chaotic and very visible series of accusations regarding on-set assault (including a settled lawsuit) and domestic violence (which you have denied), coupled with highly publicized defamation trials, have collectively damaged your previously stellar reputation. Your last major franchise character, Gellert Grindelwald in the Harry Potter Fantastic Beasts series, came to an end when Warner Bros. requested your resignation following your loss in a libel case against the Sun newspaper for labeling you a “wife beater.”
Since then, you have had limited significant appearances. Meanwhile, years of extravagant spending led you to purchase a private island and an entire French village (along with almost enough wine to intoxicate the entire nation) and accumulate debts comparable to those of some of the world’s most extravagant small countries.
What are your options?
Interestingly, for your first significant Hollywood film following the conclusion of your defamation lawsuit against ex-partner Amber Heard (a trial you largely emerged victorious from, with Heard mandated to pay you $10 million US regarding her abuse claims), you have selected Ebenezer. This is a cherished, albeit frequently retold tale. For some, this might seem more like a public relations strategy than a genuinely captivating film.
Upon reflection, remaking Charles Dickens’s A Christmas Carol could be seen as a logical choice. The story revolves around the stingy, titular Scrooge who learns to embrace Christmas and humanity through encounters with one ghost and three spirits, all set in Victorian England. You find yourself wandering through the grimy, soot-laden streets of London once more, employing the accent you have honed throughout your career that sounds convincing to Americans, yet is off-putting to Britons.
However, as you strut about in carefully worn cloaks and period-specific whimsical hats, it may be challenging for viewers to recapture the fondness they once had while watching Edward Scissorhands, Sweeney Todd, or even your portrayal of Willy Wonka in Charlie and the Chocolate Factory — all of which are modern retellings. They used to admire you, right?
This somewhat satisfactory return feels quite similar to that. Can’t they find affection for you again?
-
REVIEW
Apple TV’s Nocturne is Nordic noir by the numbers
-
REVIEW
Wild Horse Nine is a bleak, hopeless sign of the times. You’re going to love it
Truthfully, your performance is quite decent. With your expressive grimaces and exaggerated shouts, your sentimental monologues and comical wide-eyed expressions guide audiences through Dickens’s classic yet somewhat sentimental narrative of bitterness leading to redemption.
While this may not be a landmark performance in your career, nor one with significant depth or uniqueness, it does echo the roles you used to play. The quirky smirk and casually humorous dialogue that once supported blockbuster films remains present. Surely that has some value, right?
Additionally, you are backed by a stellar ensemble: Ian McKellen portrays your cautionary business partner Jacob Marley, Rupert Grint takes on the role of your overworked assistant Bob Cratchit, and Tramell Tillman embodies the ominous, pagan-like Ghost of Christmas Present.

Tramell Tillman, left, plays the Ghost of Christmas Present to Johnny Depp’s Ebenezer Scrooge in Ebenezer. (Jaap Buitendijk/Paramount Pictures)
Each actor fulfills their role: delivering pointed lines from effectively archetypical — and necessarily simplistic — characters. They aim to make your unlikable protagonist endure enough hardship so that, in the end, he appears sympathetic, humanized, and deserving of reintegration into society.
In fact, it is so familiar and characteristically Depp that audiences might find themselves half-expecting Helena Bonham Carter to appear from around every shadowy, cobblestoned street. Director Ti West (MaXXXine, Pearl, X) tries to infuse the source material with his unique campy-horror style, but rather than the captivating genre blend found in Tim Burton’s Scissorhands, what results is more akin to an afternoon pantomime.
There are excessive elements of clanking chains and moaning ghosts straight from Fleet Street central casting. West’s few original interpretations seem to aim for humor but land as offensively blunt. For instance, instead of Dickens’s trembling child-spirits symbolizing “ignorance” and “want,” we encounter monsters reminiscent of Dr. Seuss’s Thing 1 and Thing 2, screeching and scampering across the floor like miniature, transparent ankle-biters from hell.
Redemption roulette
So why did you choose this, Johnny? If you consider it, leaning on this now-familiar story instead of seeking innovation is ideal for your situation. You are not the first celebrity to inspire “fall from grace” headlines. And amid the nearly endless list of attempts to rise again, there is often a common thread.
There are less successful efforts, like Will Smith’s painfully self-punishing Emancipation, which revolves around an enslaved man who was so brutally beaten that images of his whip-scarred back played a role in abolishing slavery. Or Kevin Spacey’s amateurish The Man Who Drew God, telling the story of a blind man falsely accused of sexually assaulting a child. Then there’s Armie Hammer’s Citizen Vigilante or Jonathan Majors’s Run Hide Fight: Infidels — each focusing on a solitary man fighting against those the films portray as the scum of society.
There are also more triumphant returns. Winona Ryder made her comeback from criminal conviction obscurity with a minor role in Black Swan, but her real return to prominence came as the endlessly selfless mother in Stranger Things. After earning a reputation for poor performances both on set and at the box office, Mickey Rourke achieved a (temporarily) triumphant comeback as the battered yet valiant protagonist in The Wrestler.
-
REVIEW
Will Smith’s comeback, Emancipation, reduces a slave narrative to an action film
-
REVIEW
Tom Cruise is fantastic in Digger. You might hate it
Robert Downey Jr. perhaps exemplifies the most remarkable comeback of all time, changing public perception from substance abuse and arrests to his role as a world-saving, carefree billionaire altruist in Iron Man.
It’s important to note that the quality of a film does not correlate with whether a star is a good person or not. While not universally applicable, the successful formula is reliable: To restore a reputation after controversy, present oneself as a pitiable victim or a self-sacrificing hero (or both) in a drama that subtly reflects one’s own experiences.
Although Ebenezer may be perfectly acceptable — and as original as the novella’s entry on “Simple Wikipedia” — it at least fulfills your requirements. Based on a narrative so effective at evoking goodwill toward humanity that it essentially shaped the contemporary concept of Christmas generosity, what more could one desire?
